FROM SUBSTANTIAL BURDEN ON RELIGION TO DIMINISHED SPIRITUAL FULFILLMENT: THE SAN FRANCISCO PEAKS CASE AND THE MISUNDERSTANDING OF NATIVE AMERICAN RELIGION

In Navajo Nation v. U.S. Forest Service, 535 F.3d 1058 (9th Cir. 2008), cert. denied, 129 S. Ct. 2763 (2009), the Ninth Circuit seated en banc found that federal approval of a plan by a ski resort to make artificial snow with treated sewage effluent on Arizona's San Francisco Peaks, a mountain...

Full description

Saved in:  
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: McNally, Michael David (Author)
Format: Electronic Article
Language:English
Check availability: HBZ Gateway
Journals Online & Print:
Drawer...
Fernleihe:Fernleihe für die Fachinformationsdienste
Published: Cambridge Univ. Press [2015]
In: Journal of law and religion
Year: 2015, Volume: 30, Issue: 1, Pages: 36-64
Further subjects:B sacred lands
B Spirituality
B Hopi
B Religious Freedom Restoration Act
B San Francisco Peaks
B Navajo
B Sacred Sites
B American Indian religion
B Native American
Online Access: Presumably Free Access
Volltext (Resolving-System)
Volltext (doi)

MARC

LEADER 00000naa a22000002 4500
001 1666333093
003 DE-627
005 20190527123208.0
007 cr uuu---uuuuu
008 190527s2015 xx |||||o 00| ||eng c
024 7 |a 10.1017/jlr.2014.34  |2 doi 
035 |a (DE-627)1666333093 
035 |a (DE-599)KXP1666333093 
040 |a DE-627  |b ger  |c DE-627  |e rda 
041 |a eng 
084 |a 0  |2 ssgn 
100 1 |e VerfasserIn  |0 (DE-588)1057744360  |0 (DE-627)796204756  |0 (DE-576)413116395  |4 aut  |a McNally, Michael David 
109 |a McNally, Michael David  |a Mc Nally, Michael David  |a MacNally, Michael David  |a McNally, Michael D. 
245 1 0 |a FROM SUBSTANTIAL BURDEN ON RELIGION TO DIMINISHED SPIRITUAL FULFILLMENT  |b THE SAN FRANCISCO PEAKS CASE AND THE MISUNDERSTANDING OF NATIVE AMERICAN RELIGION  |c Michael D. McNally 
264 1 |c [2015] 
336 |a Text  |b txt  |2 rdacontent 
337 |a Computermedien  |b c  |2 rdamedia 
338 |a Online-Ressource  |b cr  |2 rdacarrier 
520 |a In Navajo Nation v. U.S. Forest Service, 535 F.3d 1058 (9th Cir. 2008), cert. denied, 129 S. Ct. 2763 (2009), the Ninth Circuit seated en banc found that federal approval of a plan by a ski resort to make artificial snow with treated sewage effluent on Arizona's San Francisco Peaks, a mountain massif held sacred by the Navajo, Hopi, and four other claimant tribes, did not violate their religious liberty under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA). The court accepted numerous factual findings about sincere religious exercise, but found federal approval of the scheme did not constitute a "substantial burden" on religion; rather, it only "decreased spiritual fulfillment" of tribal members. Despite a spirited dissent, the Ninth Circuit narrowly interpreted RFRA's language of "substantial burden" by making reference to the Supreme Court's 1988 holding in Lyng v. Northwest Cemetery Protective Association, 485 U.S. 439 (1988). This article shows how conventional wisdom about individualistic, subjective, and protean "spirituality" and in particular about "Native American spirituality" equips the court to denature highly specific and collective religious claims about the mountain by plaintiff tribes, and in turn to naturalize those claims as merely spiritual. Misrecognition of Native religions as Native spirituality then troubles the substantial burden analysis. While Navajo Nation suggests courts may never fully understand Native claims to sacred sites, the Supreme Court's 2014 holding in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby, Inc., 134 S. Ct. 2751, 2759 (2014), opens the door to revisiting the interpretive posture spelled out in Navajo Nation, and the Ninth Circuit's interpretive approach to "substantial burden" bears revisiting. 
601 |a Religion 
650 4 |a American Indian religion 
650 4 |a Hopi 
650 4 |a Native American 
650 4 |a Navajo 
650 4 |a Religious Freedom Restoration Act 
650 4 |a San Francisco Peaks 
650 4 |a sacred lands 
650 4 |a Sacred Sites 
650 4 |a Spirituality 
773 0 8 |i Enthalten in  |t Journal of law and religion  |d Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press, 1983  |g 30(2015), 1, Seite 36-64  |h Online-Ressource  |w (DE-627)461908581  |w (DE-600)2164472-X  |w (DE-576)273875132  |x 2163-3088  |7 nnns 
773 1 8 |g volume:30  |g year:2015  |g number:1  |g pages:36-64 
856 |u https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/79A44593EA1D40090FF90149DD4143C5/S0748081414000344a.pdf/div-class-title-from-substantial-burden-on-religion-to-diminished-spiritual-fulfillment-the-san-francisco-peaks-case-and-the-misunderstanding-of-native-american-religion-div.pdf  |x unpaywall  |z Vermutlich kostenfreier Zugang  |h publisher [open (via free pdf)] 
856 4 0 |u https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-law-and-religion/article/from-substantial-burden-on-religion-to-diminished-spiritual-fulfillment-the-san-francisco-peaks-case-and-the-misunderstanding-of-native-american-religion/79A44593EA1D40090FF90149DD4143C5  |x Resolving-System  |3 Volltext 
856 |u https://doi.org/10.1017/jlr.2014.34  |x doi  |3 Volltext 
951 |a AR 
ELC |a 1 
ITA |a 1  |t 1 
LOK |0 000 xxxxxcx a22 zn 4500 
LOK |0 001 3479777228 
LOK |0 003 DE-627 
LOK |0 004 1666333093 
LOK |0 005 20190527121256 
LOK |0 008 190527||||||||||||||||ger||||||| 
LOK |0 040   |a DE-Tue135  |c DE-627  |d DE-Tue135 
LOK |0 092   |o n 
LOK |0 852   |a DE-Tue135 
LOK |0 852 1  |9 00 
LOK |0 935   |a ixzs  |a ixzo 
OAS |a 1 
ORI |a SA-MARC-ixtheoa001.raw 
REL |a 1 
STA 0 0 |a Hopi,Navajo 
STB 0 0 |a Hopis,Navajos 
STC 0 0 |a Hopi,Navajos 
STD 0 0 |a Hopi,Navajo 
STF 0 0 |a 納瓦霍人 
STG 0 0 |a Hopi,Navajos 
STH 0 0 |a Навахо (народ),Хопи (народ) 
STI 0 0 |a Νάβαχο (εθνοτική ομάδα),Χόπι (εθνοτική ομάδα) 
SUB |a REL 
SYE 0 0 |a Moki,Moqui,Schinumo,Tusayan , Navaho,Diné,Nabajo,Navahos 

Similar Items

more