The coherence of equivocal penal substitution: modern and scholastic voices

In this contribution we investigate the conceptual coherence of penal substitution and its moral validity. After assessing two opposing modern contributions (Stevin Porter and Mark Murphy), we turn to Reformed and medieval scholasticism (Owen, Van Mastricht, and Duns Scotus). This scholastic manoeuv...

Full description

Saved in:  
Bibliographic Details
Authors: Labooy, Guus 1959- (Author) ; Wisse, P. M. (Author)
Format: Electronic Article
Language:English
Check availability: HBZ Gateway
Journals Online & Print:
Drawer...
Fernleihe:Fernleihe für die Fachinformationsdienste
Published: Springer Nature B. V [2019]
In: International journal for philosophy of religion
Year: 2019, Volume: 86, Issue: 3, Pages: 227-241
Standardized Subjects / Keyword chains:B Murphy, Mark C. 1968- / Porter, Steven L. 1970- / Sin / Punishment / Forgiveness of sins / Scholasticism
RelBib Classification:AB Philosophy of religion; criticism of religion; atheism
NBE Anthropology
Further subjects:B Owen
B Coherence
B Scholasticism
B Scotus
B Representative deservedness
B Penal Substitution
Online Access: Volltext (Resolving-System)

MARC

LEADER 00000caa a22000002 4500
001 1687535779
003 DE-627
005 20200826161847.0
007 cr uuu---uuuuu
008 200116s2019 xx |||||o 00| ||eng c
024 7 |a 10.1007/s11153-019-09709-y  |2 doi 
035 |a (DE-627)1687535779 
035 |a (DE-599)KXP1687535779 
040 |a DE-627  |b ger  |c DE-627  |e rda 
041 |a eng 
084 |a 0  |2 ssgn 
100 1 |e VerfasserIn  |0 (DE-588)123982200  |0 (DE-627)706497457  |0 (DE-576)293969108  |4 aut  |a Labooy, Guus  |d 1959- 
109 |a Labooy, Guus 1959-  |a Labooy, Gustaaf Harry 1959-  |a Labooy, G. H. 1959-  |a Labooy, Guus H. 1959- 
245 1 4 |a The coherence of equivocal penal substitution  |b modern and scholastic voices  |c G. H. Labooy 
264 1 |c [2019] 
336 |a Text  |b txt  |2 rdacontent 
337 |a Computermedien  |b c  |2 rdamedia 
338 |a Online-Ressource  |b cr  |2 rdacarrier 
520 |a In this contribution we investigate the conceptual coherence of penal substitution and its moral validity. After assessing two opposing modern contributions (Stevin Porter and Mark Murphy), we turn to Reformed and medieval scholasticism (Owen, Van Mastricht, and Duns Scotus). This scholastic manoeuvre sheds additional light on the analytic questions at issue. Following Owen and Scotus in their use of a relational analysis of guilt and its punishment, we argue that penal substitution is conceptually and morally coherent, albeit not univocally vis-à-vis ordinary punishment. Absent from the case of substitution is personal deservedness; herein we follow Murphy. However, this leaves open the conceptual possibility of representative deservedness (pace Murphy). 
601 |a Substitution 
601 |a Scholastik 
650 4 |a Coherence 
650 4 |a Owen 
650 4 |a Penal Substitution 
650 4 |a Representative deservedness 
650 4 |a Scholasticism 
650 4 |a Scotus 
652 |a AB:NBE 
689 0 0 |d p  |0 (DE-588)144027399  |0 (DE-627)656818484  |0 (DE-576)177055693  |2 gnd  |a Murphy, Mark C.  |d 1968- 
689 0 1 |d p  |0 (DE-588)1091566992  |0 (DE-627)852455283  |0 (DE-576)461714833  |2 gnd  |a Porter, Steven L.  |d 1970- 
689 0 2 |d s  |0 (DE-588)4058487-2  |0 (DE-627)106147102  |0 (DE-576)209126574  |2 gnd  |a Sünde 
689 0 3 |d s  |0 (DE-588)4057785-5  |0 (DE-627)106149474  |0 (DE-576)209123699  |2 gnd  |a Strafe 
689 0 4 |d s  |0 (DE-588)4058491-4  |0 (DE-627)106147099  |0 (DE-576)209126582  |2 gnd  |a Sündenvergebung 
689 0 5 |d s  |0 (DE-588)4053169-7  |0 (DE-627)104616814  |0 (DE-576)209102381  |2 gnd  |a Scholastik 
689 0 |5 (DE-627) 
700 1 |a Wisse, P. M.  |e VerfasserIn  |4 aut 
773 0 8 |i Enthalten in  |t International journal for philosophy of religion  |d Dordrecht : Springer Nature B.V, 1970  |g 86(2019), 3, Seite 227-241  |h Online-Ressource  |w (DE-627)320442098  |w (DE-600)2005049-5  |w (DE-576)103746927  |x 1572-8684  |7 nnns 
773 1 8 |g volume:86  |g year:2019  |g number:3  |g pages:227-241 
856 4 0 |u https://doi.org/10.1007/s11153-019-09709-y  |x Resolving-System 
935 |a mteo 
951 |a AR 
ELC |a 1 
ITA |a 1  |t 1 
LOK |0 000 xxxxxcx a22 zn 4500 
LOK |0 001 3575799350 
LOK |0 003 DE-627 
LOK |0 004 1687535779 
LOK |0 005 20200826161847 
LOK |0 008 200116||||||||||||||||ger||||||| 
LOK |0 035   |a (DE-Tue135)IxTheo#2020-02-28#6CAB7EB510B678F48D3E89C0BC4EFA6F2D1B5F86 
LOK |0 040   |a DE-Tue135  |c DE-627  |d DE-Tue135 
LOK |0 092   |o n 
LOK |0 852   |a DE-Tue135 
LOK |0 852 1  |9 00 
LOK |0 935   |a ixzs  |a ixzo  |a zota 
LOK |0 936ln  |0 1442042990  |a AB 
LOK |0 936ln  |0 144205168X  |a NBE 
ORI |a SA-MARC-ixtheoa001.raw 
REL |a 1 
STA 0 0 |a Forgiveness of sins,Forgiveness of sins,Sin,Punishment,Punishment,Sanction,Penalty,Punishment in art,Scholasticism,Sin,Sin 
STB 0 0 |a Peine,Peine,Punition,Châtiment,Punition,Châtiment,Punition (motif),Châtiment,Punition,Châtiment,Péché,Péché,Rémission des péchés,Scolastique 
STC 0 0 |a Escolástica,Pecado,Pecado,Pena,Pena,Castigo,Castigo,Castigo (Motivo),Castigo,Perdón de los pecados 
STD 0 0 |a Peccato,Peccato,Pena <motivo>,Pena,Castigo,Castigo,Castigo (motivo),Castigo,Perdono dei peccati,Scolastica 
STE 0 0 |a 惩罚,惩罚,惩处,处罚,惩处,处罚,经院哲学,士林哲学,罪,罪,过犯,过犯,赦罪 
STF 0 0 |a 懲罰,懲罰,懲處,處罰,懲處,處罰,經院哲學,士林哲學,罪,罪,過犯,過犯,赦罪 
STG 0 0 |a Escolástica,Pecado,Pecado,Pena,Pena,Castigo,Castigo,Castigo (Motivo),Castigo,Perdão dos pecados 
STH 0 0 |a Грех (мотив),Грех,Прощение грехов,Схоластика,Штраф <мотив>,Штраф,Наказание,Наказание (мотив) 
STI 0 0 |a Άφεση αμαρτιών,Συγχώρεση αμαρτιών,Αμαρτία (μοτίβο),Αμαρτία,Ποινή <μοτίβο>,Ποινή,Τιμωρία,Τιμωρία (μοτίβο),Σχολαστικισμός 
SUB |a REL 
SYE 0 0 |a Owen 
SYG 0 0 |a Murphy, Mark,1968- , Porter, Steve L.,1970- , Bestrafung,Strafen , Sünde , Hochscholastik 

Similar Items

more