A many-analysts approach to the relation between religiosity and well-being
The relation between religiosity and well-being is one of the most researched topics in the psychology of religion, yet the directionality and robustness of the effect remains debated. Here, we adopted a many-analysts approach to assess the robustness of this relation based on a new cross-cultural d...
Authors: | Hoogeveen, Suzanne (Author) ; Sarafoglou, Alexandra (Author) ; Aczel, Balazs (Author) ; Aditya, Yonathan (Author) ; Alayan, Alexandra J. (Author) ; Allen, Peter J. (Author) ; Altay, Sacha (Author) ; Alzahawi, Shilaan (Author) ; Amir, Yulmaida (Author) ; Anthony, Francis-Vincent 1954- (Author) ; Kwame Appiah, Obed (Author) ; Atkinson, Quentin D. (Author) ; Baimel, Adam (Author) ; Balkaya-Ince, Merve (Author) ; Balsamo, Michela (Author) ; Banker, Sachin (Author) ; Bartoš, František 1905-1973 (Author) ; Becerra, Mario (Author) ; Beffara, Bertrand (Author) ; Beitner, Julia (Author) ; Bendixen, Theiss (Author) ; Berkessel, Jana B. 1993- (Author) ; Berniūnas, Renatas (Author) ; Billet, Matthew I. (Author) ; Billingsley, Joseph (Author) ; Bortolini, Tiago (Author) ; Breitsohl, Heiko 1978- (Author) ; Bret, Amélie (Author) ; Brown, Faith L. (Author) ; Brown, Jennifer (Author) ; Brumbaugh, Claudia C. (Author) ; Buczny, Jacek (Author) ; Bulbulia, Joseph 1968- (Author) ; Caballero, Saúl (Author) ; Carlucci, Leonardo (Author) ; Carmichael, Cheryl L. (Author) ; Cattaneo, Marco E. G. V. (Author) ; Charles, Sarah J. (Author) ; Claessens, Scott (Author) ; Panagopoulos, Maxinne C. (Author) ; Costa, Angelo Brandelli (Author) ; Crone, Damien L. (Author) ; Czoschke, Stefan (Author) ; Czymara, Christian (Author) ; D'Urso, E. Damiano (Author) ; Dahlström, Örjan (Author) ; Dalla Rosa, Anna (Author) ; Danielsson, Henrik (Author) ; De Ron, Jill (Author) ; de Vries, Ymkje Anna (Author) ; Dean, Kristy K. (Author) ; Dik, Bryan (Author) ; Disabato, David J. (Author) ; Doherty, Jaclyn K. (Author) ; Draws, Tim (Author) ; Drouhot, Lucas (Author) ; Dujmovic, Marin (Author) ; Dunham, Yarrow (Author) ; Ebert, Tobias (Author) ; Edelsbrunner, Peter A. (Author) ; Eerland, Anita (Author) ; Elbaek, Christian T. (Author) ; Farahmand, Shole (Author) ; Farahmand, Hooman (Author) ; Farias, Miguel (Author) ; Feliccia, Abrey A. (Author) ; Fischer, Kyle (Author) ; Fischer, Ronald (Author) ; Fisher-Thompson, Donna (Author) ; Francis, Zoë (Author) ; Frick, Susanne (Author) ; Frisch, Lisa K. (Author) ; Geraldes, Diogo (Author) ; Gerdin, Emily (Author) ; Geven, Linda (Author) ; Ghasemi, Omid (Author) ; Gielens, Erwin (Author) ; Gligorić, Vukašin (Author) ; Hagel, Kristin 1981- (Author) ; Hajdu, Nandor (Author) ; Hamilton, Hannah R. (Author) ; Hamzah, Imaduddin (Author) ; Hanel, Paul H. P. (Author) ; Hawk, Christopher E. (Author) ; K. Himawan, Karel (Author) ; Holding, Benjamin C. (Author) ; Homman, Lina E. (Author) ; Ingendahl, Moritz 1996- (Author) ; Inkilä, Hilla (Author) ; Inman, Mary L. (Author) ; Islam, Chris-Gabriel (Author) ; Isler, Ozan (Author) ; Izydorczyk, David 1991- (Author) ; Jaeger, Bastian (Author) ; Johnson, Kathryn A. (Author) ; Jong, Jonathan (Author) ; Karl, Johannes A. (Author) ; Kaszubowski, Erikson (Author) ; Katz, Benjamin A. (Author) ; Keefer, Lucas A. (Author) ; Kelchtermans, Stijn 1979- (Author) ; Kelly, John M. (Author) ; Klein, Richard A. (Author) ; Kleinberg, Bennett (Author) ; Knowles, Megan L. (Author) ; Kołczyńska, Marta (Author) ; Koller, Dave (Author) ; Krasko, Julia 1986- (Author) ; Kritzler, Sarah 1995- (Author) ; Krypotos, Angelos-Miltiadis (Author) ; Kyritsis, Thanos (Author) ; L. Landes, Todd (Author) ; Laukenmann, Ruben (Author) ; Forsyth, Guy A. Lavender (Author) ; Lazar, Aryeh (Author) ; Lehman, Barbara J. (Author) ; Levy, Neil (Author) ; Lo, Ronda F. (Author) ; Lodder, Paul (Author) ; Lorenz, Jennifer (Author) ; Łowicki, Paweł (Author) ; Ly, Albert L. (Author) ; Maaßen, Esther 1976- (Author) ; Magyar-Russell, Gina M. (Author) ; Maier, Maximilian (Author) ; Marsh, Dylan R. (Author) ; Martinez, Nuria (Author) ; Martinie, Marcellin (Author) ; Martoyo, Ihan 1973- (Author) ; Mason, Susan E. (Author) ; Mauritsen, Anne Lundahl (Author) ; McAleer, Phil (Author) ; McCauley, Thomas (Author) ; McCullough, Michael (Author) ; McKay, Ryan (Author) ; McMahon, Camilla M. (Author) ; McNamara, Amelia A. (Author) ; Means, Kira K. (Author) ; Mercier, Brett (Author) ; Mitkidis, Panagiotis (Author) ; Monin, Benoît (Author) ; Moon, Jordan W. (Author) ; Moreau, David 1976- (Author) ; Morgan, Jonathan (Author) ; Murphy, James (Author) ; Muscatt, George (Author) ; Nägel, Christof (Author) ; Nagy, Tamás (Author) ; Nalborczyk, Ladislas (Author) ; Nilsonne, Gustav (Author) ; Noack, Pamina (Author) ; Norenzayan, Ara 1970- (Author) ; Nuijten, Michèle B. (Author) ; Olsson-Collentine, Anton (Author) ; Oviedo Torró, Lluís 1958- (Author) ; Pavlov, Yuri G. 1987- (Author) ; Pawelski, James O. 1967- (Author) ; Pearson, Hannah I. (Author) ; Pedder, Hugo (Author) ; Peetz, Hannah K. (Author) ; Pinus, Michael (Author) ; Pirutinsky, Steven (Author) ; Polito, Vince (Author) ; Porubanova, Michaela (Author) ; Poulin, Michael J. (Author) ; Prenoveau, Jason Matthew 1973- (Author) ; Prince, Mark A. (Author) ; Protzko, John (Author) ; Pryor, Campbell (Author) ; Purzycki, Benjamin G. (Author) ; Qiu, Lin (Author) ; Quevedo Pütter, Julian (Author) ; Rabelo, André (Author) ; Radell, Milen L. (Author) ; Ramsay, Jonathan E. (Author) ; Reid, Graham (Author) ; J. Roberts, Andrew (Author) ; Luna, Lindsey M. Root (Author) ; Ross, Robert M. (Author) ; Roszak, Piotr 1978- (Author) ; Roy, Nirmal Chandra 1988- (Author) ; Saarelainen, Suvi-Maria K. (Author) ; Sasaki, Joni Y. (Author) ; Schaumans, Catherine 1981- (Author) ; Schivinski, Bruno (Author) ; Schmitt, Marcel C. (Author) ; Schnitker, Sarah A. (Author) ; Schnürch, Martin 1991- (Author) ; Schreiner, Marcel R. (Author) ; Schüttengruber, Victoria (Author) ; Sebben, Simone (Author) ; Segerstrom, Suzanne C. (Author) ; Seryczyńska, Berenika (Author) ; Shjoedt, Uffe (Author) ; Simsek, Müge (Author) ; Sleegers, Willem W. A. (Author) ; Smith, Eliot R. (Author) ; Sowden, Walter J. (Author) ; Späth, Marion (Author) ; Spörlein, Christoph 1985- (Author) ; Stedden, William (Author) ; Stoevenbelt, Andrea H. (Author) ; Stuber, Simon (Author) ; Sulik, Justin (Author) ; Suwartono, Christiany (Author) ; Syropoulos, Stylianos (Author) ; Szaszi, Barnabas (Author) ; Szecsi, Peter (Author) ; Tappin, Ben M. (Author) ; Tay, Louis ca. 20./21. Jh. (Author) ; Thibault, Robert T. (Author) ; Thompson, Burt (Author) ; Thurn, Christian M. (Author) ; Torralba, Josefa (Author) ; Tuthill, Shelby D. (Author) ; Ullein, Ann-Marie (Author) ; Aert, Robbie C. M. van (Author) ; van Assen, Marcel A. L. M. (Author) ; Van Cappellen, Patty (Author) ; Akker, Olmo R. van den (Author) ; Van der Cruyssen, Ine (Author) ; Van der Noll, Jolanda (Author) ; van Dongen, Noah N. N. (Author) ; Van Lissa, Caspar J. (Author) ; Mulukom, Valerie van (Author) ; van Ravenzwaaij, Don (Author) ; van Zyl, Casper J. J. (Author) ; Ann Vaughn, Leigh (Author) ; Većkalov, Bojana (Author) ; Verschuere, Bruno (Author) ; Vianello, Michelangelo (Author) ; Vilanova, Felipe (Author) ; Vishkin, Allon (Author) ; Vogel, Vera (Author) ; Vogelsmeier, Leonie V. D. E. (Author) ; Watanabe, Shoko (Author) ; White, Cindel J. M. (Author) ; Wiebels, Kristina (Author) ; Wiechert, Sera (Author) ; Willett, Zachary Z. (Author) ; Witkowiak, Maciej (Author) ; Witvliet, Charlotte V. O. (Author) ; Wiwad, Dylan (Author) ; Wuyts, Robin (Author) ; Xygalatas, Dēmētrēs 1977- (Author) ; Yang, Xin (Author) ; Yeo, Darren J. (Author) ; Yilmaz, Onurcan (Author) ; Zarzeczna, Natalia (Author) ; Zhao, Yitong (Author) ; Zijlmans, Josjan (Author) ; Elk, Michiel van 1980- (Author) ; Wagenmakers, Eric-Jan 1972- (Author) |
---|---|
Format: | Electronic Article |
Language: | English |
Check availability: | HBZ Gateway |
Journals Online & Print: | |
Fernleihe: | Fernleihe für die Fachinformationsdienste |
Published: |
Routledge
2023
|
In: |
Religion, brain & behavior
Year: 2023, Volume: 13, Issue: 3, Pages: 237-283 |
Further subjects: | B
many analysts
B Open scholarship B Health B Religion |
Online Access: |
Volltext (kostenfrei) |
Summary: | The relation between religiosity and well-being is one of the most researched topics in the psychology of religion, yet the directionality and robustness of the effect remains debated. Here, we adopted a many-analysts approach to assess the robustness of this relation based on a new cross-cultural dataset (N=10,535 participants from 24 countries). We recruited 120 analysis teams to investigate (1) whether religious people self-report higher well-being, and (2) whether the relation between religiosity and self-reported well-being depends on perceived cultural norms of religion (i.e., whether it is considered normal and desirable to be religious in a given country). In a two-stage procedure, the teams first created an analysis plan and then executed their planned analysis on the data. For the first research question, all but 3 teams reported positive effect sizes with credible/confidence intervals excluding zero (median reported β=0.120). For the second research question, this was the case for 65% of the teams (median reported β=0.039). While most teams applied (multilevel) linear regression models, there was considerable variability in the choice of items used to construct the independent variables, the dependent variable, and the included covariates. |
---|---|
ISSN: | 2153-5981 |
Contains: | Enthalten in: Religion, brain & behavior
|
Persistent identifiers: | DOI: 10.1080/2153599X.2022.2070255 |
Similar Items
-
Religie in het netwerk van alledag
by: van Ouwerkerk, C. A. J.
Published: (1993) -
Memorandum on the Financing of Voluntary Migration
by: Grevenstein, J. A. U. M. van
Published: (1956) -
The Soft-spoken Inspiration: International Cooperation and Christian Social Tradition
by: Gennip, Jos J. A. M. van
Published: (2007) -
Women and the spread of islam in West Africa: their changing position in a North Cameroonian town
by: Santen, J. C. M. van
Published: (1995) -
Gaul
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Apollinaris of Valence
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Marcian
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Merobaudes
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Honoratus Antoninus
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Haager Gesellschaft
by: Belzen, J.A. van
Published: (2015) -
Jung, Carl Gustav
by: Belzen, J.A. van
Published: (2015) -
Der Chiasmus der niederländischen Religionspsychologie
by: Van Belzen, J.A.
Published: (1992) -
Psychologische Theorieentwicklung über das Verhältnis zwischen geistlicher Gesundheit und Religion
by: Van Belzen, J.A.
Published: (1985) -
Sur quelques termes Indo-Iraniens empruntés par le tokharien
by: Van Windekens, A. J.
Published: (1972) -
Maslow, Abraham Harold
by: Belzen, J.A. van
Published: (2015) -
Eucherius of Lyon
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Paulinus of Pella
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Auspicius of Toul
by: Waarden, J. A. van
Published: (2018) -
Minds, Forms, and Spirits: The Nature of Cartesian Disenchantment
by: Ruler, J. A. van
Published: (2000) -
The end justifies all means: questionable conversion of different effect sizes to a common effect size measure
by: van Assen, Marcel A.L.M., et al.
Published: (2023)